GUIDELINES FOR OBJECTIVE REVIEW OF MANUSCRIPTS
SCORE GUIDE (To be used by the Referee/Reviewer)
|
Not Given/Not Relevant |
0 |
|
Below Standard |
1 |
|
Average |
2 |
|
Satisfactory |
3 |
|
Good |
4 |
|
Very Good |
5 |
Manuscript Reg. No...................................................... Reviewer’s Name.........................................................
|
Description of the Part of Manuscript |
Score |
|
TITLE |
|
|
Accurate |
|
|
Effective |
|
|
RepTesents Main Message of Paper |
|
|
ABSTRACT |
|
|
Size of abstract |
|
|
Summary of Introduction |
|
|
Study Design |
|
|
Material and Methods |
|
|
Results |
|
|
Discussion |
|
|
Conclusion |
|
|
DIFFICULT WORDS/KEY WORDS IF RELEVANT |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
INTRODUCTION |
|
|
If start Relevant |
|
|
Subject of Paper Made Clear |
|
|
Importance of Study Made Clear |
|
|
Reasons for the Study Stated |
|
|
Significant finding of the Study Stated |
|
|
International Literature of past 10 years Recorded. |
|
|
National Literature of past 10 years Recorded |
|
|
Ancient Literature Reviewed and Recorded |
|
|
References appropriate for Discussion not given in Introduction |
|
|
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY |
|
|
Are clearly Stated |
|
|
Are addressed in the study |
|
|
MATERIAL AND METHODS |
|
|
Population of uniform standard |
|
|
Sample selection criteria reliable |
|
|
Inclusion/Exclusion criteria specified |
|
|
Control within the study or literature given |
|
|
Important Variable Measurement Criteria specified.. |
|
|
Criteria to measure outcome relevant |
|
|
Investigation/Procedure/Technique clearly given |
|
|
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS OF RESULTS |
|
|
Presentation of results clear |
|
|
Data satisfies objectives of the study |
|
|
All subjects/Variable in the study accounted for.. |
|
|
Results reported the drop out (if present) |
|
|
Results presented in Free |
|
|
Results presented with Frequency Distribution |
|
|
Results presented with standard deviation |
|
|
Appropriate statistical tests applied |
|
|
Data Analysis correctly interpreted |
|
|
Level of significance (preferred less than 0.1%).. |
|
|
DISCUSSION |
|
|
Important findings and results discussed |
|
|
New emerging findings discussed |
|
|
Results of the study discussed with others in literature |
|
|
Questions raised in the study |
|
|
Results and analysis leads to firm conclusions |
|
|
CONCLUSIONS |
|
|
Conclusions justified by the results/findings |
|
|
Conclusions relevant to the aims and objectives of the study. |
|
|
Conclusions based on critical argument |
|
|
WRITTEN ENGLISH |
|
|
Spellings |
|
|
Grammar |
|
|
REPORT (State clearly approved-advised revision rejected) |
|
Reviewer Signature…………………………. Date……………….
support@medicalchanneljournal.pk
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives (CC BY-NC-ND) license. Open Access Publication.
